Reflections on Quasi-Indexicals, Self-Consciousness and Self-Knowledge

Giuseppe Mario Antonio Varnier


Abstract: Building on recent linguistic and philosophical research on quasi-indexicals, self-consciousness, anaphora, and discours indirect libre, I argue that they raise problems (as already pointed out by Castañeda and others) for the definition of (de se) self-knowledge understood according to the Classical Definition of Knowledge (conceived as expressing at least the necessary conditions for knowledge, if not a sufficient set of conditions). I call this extremely difficult problem the “non-detachment problem”. I show that, for this reason, self-knowledge must always be considered perspectival and non-third-personal, in the relevant cases. I also discuss and criticize the Lewis-Chierchia interpretation of de se attitudes. Furthermore, I discuss the role of the (a) self in the strict sense in an adequate account of so-called self-knowledge, and in a problem closely related to the “non-detachment problem”, that of the reconstruction of the cogito.

Keywords: Indexicals; Quasi-indexicals; Classical (tripartite) Definition of Knowledge; Self-knowledge; Self-consciousness


Considerazioni su quasi-indicali, autoriferimento e conoscenza di sé

Riassunto: Sulla base di recenti ricerche linguistiche e filosofiche sui quasi-indicali, l‘autocoscienza, l’anafora e il discours indirect libre, intendo sostenere che essi sollevano difficoltà, già anticipate da Castañeda e altri, per la definizione della conoscenza di sé (nel senso del de se), se essa è pensata secondo la definizione classica di conoscenza considerata almeno come condizione necessaria della conoscenza. Chiamo questo problema di difficilissima soluzione il “problema della non distaccabilità”. Cercherò di mostrare che, di conseguenza, la conoscenza di sé deve essere intesa come sempre “prospettica” e non di terza persona, nei casi rilevanti. Intendo poi discutere criticamente l’interpretazione di Lewis e Chierchia delle attitudini de se. Inoltre, discuto il ruolo del (o di un) in senso stretto in un resoconto adeguato della cosiddetta conoscenza di sé e in un problema prossimo a quello della “non distaccabilità”: il problema della ricostruzione del cogito.

Parole chiave: Indicali; Quasi-indicali; Definizione classica (tripartita) della conoscenza; Conoscenza di sé; autocoscienza

Parole chiave

Indexicals; Quasi-indexicals; Classical (tripartite) Definition of Knowledge; Self-knowledge; Self-consciousness

Full Text


Riferimenti bibliografici

BANFIELD, A. (1982), Unspeakable Sentences. Narration and Representation in the Language of Fiction, Routledge & Kegan Paul, Boston/London/Melbourne.

CARL, W. (2014), The First Person Point of View, de Gruyter, Berlin / New York.

CHIERCHIA, G. (1989), Anaphora and de se Expressions. In: R.R. BARTSCH, J.F.A.K. VAN BENTHEM (eds.), Semantics and Contextual Expressions, Foris Publications, Indianapolis, pp. 1-31.

CORAZZA, E. (2004), Essential Indexicals and Quasi‐Indicators. In: «Journal of Semantics», vol. XXI, n. 4, pp. 341-374.

CORAZZA, E. (2004), Reflecting the Mind: Indexicality and Quasi-Indexicality, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

GEACH, P. (1957), On Beliefs about Oneself. In: «Analysis», vol. XVIII, 1, pp. 23-24.

HIGGINBOTHAM, J. (2010), On Words and Thoughts about Oneself. In: F. RECANATI, I. STOJANOVIC, N. VILLANUEVA (eds.), Context-Dependence, Perspective and Relativity, de Gruyter, Berlin/New York, pp. 253-282.

HINTIKKA, J. (1996), Cogito, Ergo Quis Est?. In: «Revue Internationale de Philosophie», vol. L, n. 195, pp. 5-21.

HINTIKKA, J. (1998), Perspectival Identification, Demonstratives and “Small Worlds”. In: «Synthese», vol. CXIV, n. 2, pp. 203-232.

KAMERMANS, M. (2010), An Introduction to Japanese. Grammar Syntax and Language, on-line version April, 26th.

KRIPKE, S. (2011), Philosophical Troubles, Oxford University Press, Oxford/New York.

LEWIS, D.K. (1979/1983), Attitudes de dicto and de se. In: D.K. LEWIS, Philosophical Papers, vol. I, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 133-159.

LYCAN, S., BOËR, S. (1986), Knowing Who, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

MAY, R. (2006), Frege on Indexicals. In: «Philosophical Review», vol. CXV, n. 4, pp. 487-516.

MORAN, R. (2001), Authority and Estrangement: An Essay on Self-knowledge, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

PERRY, J. (1979), The Problem of the Essential Indexical. In: «Nous», vol. XIII, pp. 3-21.

RAPAPORT, W.J. (1998), Prolegomena to a Study of Hector-Neri Castaneda’s Influence on Artificial Intelligence: A Survey and Personal Reflections. In: F. ORILIA, W.J. RAPAPORT (eds.), Thought, Language and Ontology. Essays in Memory of Hector-Neri Castañeda, Dordrecht/Boston/London pp. 345-367.

RAPAPORT, W.J., SHAPIRO, S.C., WIEBE, J.M. (1997), Quasi-indexicals and Knowledge Reports. In: «Cognitive Science», vol. XXI, n. 1, pp. 63-107.

SCHLENKER, P. (1999), Propositional Attitudes and Indexicality: A Cross-categorial Approach, MIT Doctoral Dissertation.

SCHLENKER, P. (2004), Context of Thought and Context of Utterance (A Note on Free Indirect Discourse and the Historical Present). In: «Mind and Language», vol. XIX, n. 3, pp. 279-304.

SCHLENKER, P. (2011), Indexicality and De Se Reports. In: K. VON HEUSINGER, C. MAIENBORN, P. PORTNER (eds.), Semantics: An International Handbook of Natural Language Meaning, vol. II, de Gruyter, Berlin/New York, pp. 1-41.

SCHLENKER, P. (2000), Indexicality, Logophoricity, and Plural Pronouns. In: J. LECARME (ed.), Research in Afroasiatic Grammar II, Selected Papers from the Fifth Conference on Afroasiatic Languages, Benjamins, Amsterdam/Paris, pp. 409-428.

SCHLENKER, P. (2003), A Plea for Monsters. In: «Linguistics and Philosophy», vol. XXVI, n. 1, pp. 29-120.

SHOEMAKER, S. (1968), Self-Reference and Self-Awareness. In: «The Journal of Philosophy», vol. LXV, n. 19, pp. 555-567.

SHOEMAKER, S. (1986), Introspection and the Self. In: «Midwest Studies in Philosophy», vol. X, pp. 101-120.

STRAWSON, G. (2004), Against Narrativity. In: «Ratio», vol. XVII, n. 1, pp. 428-452.

STRAWSON, G. (2006) Realistic Monism: Why Physicalism Entails Panpsychism. In: «Journal of Consciousness Studies», vol. XIII, n. 10-11, pp. 3-31.

STRAWSON, G. (2011), The Evident Connexion: Hume on Personal Identity, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

STRAWSON, G. (2011), The Minimal Subject. In: S. GALLAGHER (ed.), Oxford Handbook of the Self, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 253-278.

STRAWSON, G. (ed.) (2006), Consciousness and Its Place in Nature, Imprint Academic, Charlottesville (VA).

VARNIER, G. (2014), Quasi-Indexicals, Kaplanian Monsters, and Self-Consciousness. In: A. PALMA (ed.), (Hector-Neri) Castañeda and his Guises, de Gruyter, Berlin/Boston, pp. 161-185.


Copyright (c) 2017 Giuseppe Mario Antonio Varnier

URLdella licenza:

Rivista internazionale di Filosofia e Psicologia - ISSN: 2039-4667 (print) - E-ISSN: 2239-2629 (online)

Registrazione al Tribunale di Milano n. 634 del 26-11-2010 - Direttore Responsabile: Aurelia Delfino

Web provider Aruba spa - Loc. Palazzetto, 4 - 52011 Bibbiena (AR) - P.IVA 01573850516 - C.F. e R.I./AR 04552920482

Licenza Creative Commons
Dove non diversamente specificato, i contenuti di Rivista Internazionale di Filosofia e Psicologia sono distribuiti con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione 4.0 Internazionale.