Pain and Consciousness in Humans. Or Why Pain Subserves the Identity and Self-representation
Abstract
Abstract: Traditional definitions of pain assume that an individual learns about pain through verbal usages related to the experience of injury in early life. This emphasis on the verbal correlates of pain restricts our understanding of pain to the context of adult human consciousness. In this paper we instead support the idea that our understanding of pain originates in neonatal experience and is not merely a verbally determined phenomenon. We also challenge the definition of pain as a merely sensory message related to peripheral tissue trauma. We aim to move beyond this definition by considering the relationship between the centre (Central Nervous System) and periphery, taking into account certain phenomena such as phantom limbs and interoception. We show that pain helps an individual to develop a sense of awareness of himself immersed in a social context, and is thus a complex and adaptive phenomenon, that supports bodily integrity and social behavior.
Keywords: Awareness; Consciousness; Experience; Pain; Self-representation
Dolore e coscienza negli esseri umani. Ovvero, perché il dolore favorisce l’identità e la rappresentazione di sé
Riassunto: La definizione classica di dolore presuppone che l’individuo ne apprenda l'uso verbale attraverso esperienze dolorifiche legate all’infanzia, favorendo una maggiore attenzione per i correlati verbali del dolore. Questo spesso relega il dolore nel contesto della coscienza dell’uomo adulto. Il presente lavoro si propone, in primo luogo, di sottolineare alcune evidenze, a partire dall'esperienza neonatale, a sostegno dell’idea di dolore come esperienza umana e non solo come fenomeno determinato verbalmente. Un secondo aspetto emerge dalla definizione di dolore, il concepirlo come un semplice messaggio sensoriale in seguito a lesioni dei tessuti periferici. Ci si propone, pertanto, di andare oltre tale ipotesi considerando il rapporto tra centro (Sistema Nervoso Centrale) e periferia, a partire da alcuni fenomeni come l’arto fantasma e l’interocezione. Il dolore aiuta inoltre a sviluppare un senso di consapevolezza di sé immerso nel contesto sociale; si tratta dunque di un fenomeno complesso e adattivo, dall’integrità fisica alla dimensione sociale.
Parole chiave: Consapevolezza; Coscienza; Esperienza; Dolore; Rappresentazione di sé
Parole chiave
Full Text
PDFRiferimenti bibliografici
AITKEN, K.J., TREVARTHEN, C. (1997), Self/Other Organization in Human Psychological Development. In: «Development and Psychopathology», vol. IX, n. 4, pp. 653-677.
ALLEGRI, M., LUCIONI, C., MAZZI, S., SERRA, G. (2015), Il costo sociale del dolore cronico in Italia. In: «Global and Regional Health Technology Assessment», vol. II, n. 1, pp. 33-42.
ALS, H. (1998), Developmental Care in the Newborn Intensive Care Unit. In: «Current Opinion in Pediatrics», vol. X, n. II, pp. 138-142.
ANAND, K.J.S., CRAIG, K.D. (1996), New Perspectives on the Definition of Pain. In: «Pain», vol. LXVII, n. 1, pp. 3-6.
ANAND, K.J.S., ROVNAGHI, C., MARLENE WALDEN, M., CHURCHILL, J. (1999), Consciousness, Behavior, and Clinical Impact of the Definition of Pain. In: «Pain Forum», vol. VIII, n. 2, pp. 64-73.
ARDUINI, D., RIZZO, G., GIORLANDINO, C., VALENSISE, H., DELL’ACQUA, D., ROMANINI, C. (1986), The Development of Fetal Behavioral States: A Longitudinal Study. In: «Prenatal Diagnosis», vol. VI, n. 2, pp. 117-124.
BALCONI, M., BORTOLOTTI, A. (2014), Self-report, Personality and Autonomic System Modulation in Response to Empathic Conflictual versus Non Conflictual Situation. In: «Cognition and Emotion», vol. XXVIII, n. 1, pp. 153-162.
BONICA, J.J. (1953), The Management of Pain, Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia.
BRENER, J., KLUVITSE, C. (1988), Heartbeat Detection: Judgments of the Simultaneity of External Stimuli and Heartbeats. In: «Psychophysiology», vol. XXV, n. 5, pp. 554-561.
BROOKS, J.C., NURMIKKO, T.J., BIMSON, W.E., SINGH, K.D., ROBERTS, N. (2002), fMRI of Thermal Pain: Effects of Stimulus Laterality and Attention. In: «NeuroImage», vol. XV, n. 2, pp. 293-301.
BROWN, J.D. (1998), The Self, McGraw-Hill, Boston.
CAMERON, O.G. (2001), Interoception: The Inside Story – A Model for Psychosomatic Processes. In: «Psychosomatic Medicine», vol. LXIII, n. 5, pp. 697-710.
CANNON, W.B. (1963), Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, Fear and Rage, an Account of Researches into the Function of Emotional Excitement, Harper & Row, New York, II ed.
CAREL, H. (2012), Nursing and Medicine. In: S. LUFT, S. OVERGAARD (eds.), The Routledge Companion to Phenomenology, Routledge, London/NewYork, pp. 623-632.
CERVERO, F., JANIG, W. (1992), Visceral Nociceptors: A New World Order?. In: «Trends in Neuroscience», vol. XV, n. 10, pp. 374-378.
CEUNEN, E., VAN DIEST, I., VLAEYEN, J.W. (2013), Accuracy and Awareness of Perception: Related, yet Distinct. In: «Biological Psychology», vol. XCII, n. 2, pp. 426-427.
CHAPMAN, C.R., NAKAMURA, Y. (1999), A Passion of the Soul: An Introduction to Pain for Consciousness Researchers. In: «Consciousness and Cognition», vol. VIII, n. 4, pp. 391-422.
CRAIG, A.D. (2002) How do you Feel? Interoception: The Sense of the Physiological Condition of the Body. In: «Nature Reviews. Neuroscience», vol. III, n. 8, pp. 655-666.
CRAIG, A.D. (2003), Interoception: The Sense of the Physiological Condition of the Body. In: «Current Opinion in Neurobiology», vol. XIII, n. 4, pp. 500-505.
CRAIG, K.D. (1997), Implications of Concepts of Consciousness for Understanding Pain Behaviour and the Definition of Pain. In: «Pain Research and Management», vol. II, n. 2, pp. 111-117.
CRITCHLEY, H.D., MELMED, R.N., FEATHERSTONE, E., MATHIAS, C.J., DOLAN, R.J. (2002), Volitional Control of Autonomic Arousal: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Study. In: «NeuroImage», vol. XVI, n. 4, pp. 909-919.
CRITCHLEY, H.D., WIENS, S., ROTSHTEIN,P., OHMAN, A., DOLAN, R.J. (2004), Neural Systems Supporting Interoceptive Awareness. In: «Nature Neuroscience», vol. VII, n. 2, 2004, pp. 189-195.
DAMASIO, A.R. (1994), Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain, Putnam, New York.
DAMASIO, A.R., GRABOWSKI, T.J., BECHARA, A., DAMASIO, H., PONTO, L.L., PARVIZI, J., HICHWA, R.D. (2000), Subcortical and Cortical Brain Activity During the Feeling of Self-generated Emotions. In: «Natural Neuroscience», vol. III, n. 10, pp. 1049-1056.
DE VRIES, J., VISSIER, G., PRECHT, H. (1982), The Emergence of Fetal Behavior. In: «Early Human Developement», vol. XII, n. 2, pp. 301-322.
DERBYSHIRE, S. (1996), Comment on Editorial by Anand and Craig. In: «Pain», vol. LXVII, n. 1, pp. 210-211.
DERBYSHIRE, S.W., JONES, A.K. (1998), Cerebral Responses to a Continual Tonic Pain Stimulus Measured Using Positron Emission Tomography. In: «Pain», vol. LXXVI, n. 1-2, pp. 127-135.
DUSCHEK, S., MONTORO, C.I., REYES DEL PASO, G.A. (2015), Diminished Interoceptive Awareness in Fibromyalgia Syndrome. In: «Behavioural Medicine», online first 2015, October 2nd - doi: 10.1080/08964289.2015.1094442.
FARB, N., DAUBENMIER, J., PRICE, C.J., GARD, T., KERR, C., DUNN, B.D., KLEIN, A.C., PAULUS, M.P., MEHLING, W.E. (2015), Interoception, Contemplative Practice, and Health. In: «Frontiers in Psychology», vol. VI, Art. Nr. 763.
FIELDS, H. (2007), Setting the Stage for Pain: Allegorical Tales from Neuroscience. In: S. COAKLEY, K.K. SHELEMAY (eds.), Pain and Its Transformations: The Interface of Biology and Culture, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA), pp. 36-61.
FLOR, H., FURST, M., BIRBAUMER, N. (1999), Deficient Discrimination of EMG Levels and Overestimation of Perceived Tension in Chronic Pain Patients. In: «Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback», vol. XXIV, n. 1, pp. 55-66.
FRY, C.L. (2009), A Descriptive Social Neuroethics is Needed to Reveal Lived Identities. In: «The American Journal of Bioethics-Neuroscience», vol. IX, n. 9, pp. 16-17.
GARFINKEL, S.N., SETH, A.K., BARRETT, A.B., SUZUKI, K., CRITCHLEY, H.D. (2015), Knowing Your Own Heart: Distinguishing Interoceptive Accuracy from Interoceptive Awareness. In: «Biological Psychology», n. 104, pp. 65-74.
GILLETT, G.R. (2009), The Subjective Brain, Identity, and Neuroethics. In: «American Journal of Bioethics», vol. IX, n. 9, pp. 5-13.
GOLDBERG, D. (2009), Subjectivity, Consciousness, and Pain: The Importance of Thinking Phenomenologically. In: «The American Journal of Bioethics», vol. IX, n. 9, pp. 14-33.
HEPPER, P.G., SHAHIDULLAH, S. (1994), The Beginnings of Mind-evidence from the Behavior of the Fetus. In: «Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology», vol. XII, n. 3, pp. 143-154.
HOFBAUER, R.K., RAINVILLE, P., DUNCAN, G.H., BUSHNELL, M.C. (2001), Cortical Representation of the Sensory Dimension of Pain. In: «Journal of Neurophysiology», vol. LXXXVI, n. 1, pp. 402-411.
IGGO, A. (1960), Cutaneous Mechanoreceptors with Afferent C Fibres. In: «Journal of Physiology», vol. CLII, n. 2, pp. 337-353.
JAMES, W. (1900), The Principles of Psychology, Chicago, Encyclopaedia Britannica.
KLIMACH, V., COOKE, R.W.L. (1988), Maturation of the Neonatal Somatosensory Evoked Response in Preterm Infants. In: «Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology», vol. XXX, n. 2, pp. 208-214.
KOMESAROFF, P. (2008), Experiments in Love and Death: Medicine, Postmernism, Microethics and the Body, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne.
KUPERS, R.C., GYBELS, J.M., GJEDDE, A. (2000), Positron Emission Tomography Study of a Chronic Pain Patient Successfully Treated with Somatosensory Thalamic Stimulation. In: «Pain», vol. LXXXVII, n. 3, pp. 295-302.
LIMA, M.C., FREGNI, F. (2008), Motor Cortex Stimulation for Chronic Pain: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of the Literature. In: «Neurology», vol. LXX, n. 24, pp. 2329-2337.
LLOYD-THOMAS, A.R., FITZGERALD, M. (1996), Do Fetuses Feel Pain? Reflex Responses do not Necessarily Signify Pain. In: «British Medical Journal», vol. CCCXIII, n. 7060, pp. 797-798.
LONGO, M.R., AZANON, E., HAGGARD, P. (2010), More than Skin Deep: Body Representation Beyond Primary Somatosensory Cortex. In: «Neuropsychologia», vol. XLVIII, n. 3, pp. 655-668.
M. MERLEAU-PONTY (1945/2005), Phenomenology of Perception, edited by C. SMITH, Routledge, London.
MACLEAN, P.D. (1990), The Triune Brain in Evolution. Role in Paleocerebral Functions, Plenum, New York/London 1990.
MAIHOFNER, C., SEIFERT, F., DECOL, R. (2001), Activation of Central Sympathetic Networks During Innocuous and Noxious Somatosensory Stimulation. In: «NeuroImage», vol. LV, n. 1, pp. 216-224.
MELZACK, R. (1989), Phantom Limbs, the Self and the Brain (the D.O. Hebb Memorial Lecture). In: «Canadian Psychology», vol. XXX, n. 1, pp. 1-14.
MELZACK, R. (1990), Phantom Limbs and the Concept of a Neuromatrix. In: «Trends in Neuroscience», vol. XIII, n. 3, pp. 88-92.
MELZACK, R. (1999), From the Gate to the Neuromatrix. In: «Pain - Supplements», vol. VI, pp. 121-126.
MELZACK, R. (1999), Pain – An Overview. In: «Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica», vol. XLIII, n. 9, pp. 880-884.
MELZACK, R. (2001), Pain and the Neuromatrix in the Brain. In: «Journal of Dental Education», vol. LXV, n. 12, pp. 1378-1382.
MELZACK, R. (2005) Evolution of the Neuromatrix Theory of Pain. The Prithvi Raj Lecture. In: «Pain Practice», vol. V, n. 2, pp. 85-94.
MELZACK, R.W. (1996), The Challenge of Pain, Penguin, London, II ed.
MENSE, S., MEYER, H. (1985), Different Types of Slowly Conducting Afferent Units in Cat Skeletal Muscle and Tendon. In: «Journal of Physiology», n. 363, pp. 403-417.
MERSKEY, H. (1997), Pain, Consciousness, and Behavior. In: «Pain Research and Management», vol. II, n. 2, pp. 118-122.
MERSKEY, H., BOGDUK, N. (eds.) (1994), Classification of Chronic Pain: Descriptions of Chronic Pain Syndromes and Definitions of Pain Terms, II ed., IASP Press, Seattle.
MICHAEL, G.A., NAVETEUR, J. (2011), The Tickly Homunculus and the Origins of Spontaneous Sensations Arising on the Hands. In: «Conscious and Cognition», vol. XX, n. 3, pp. 603-617.
MICHAEL, G.A., NAVETEUR, J., DUPUY, M.A., JACQUOT, L. (2015), My Heart is in My Hands: The Interoceptive Nature of the Spontaneous Sensations Felt on the Hands. In: «Physiology and Behaviour», n. 143, pp. 113-120, online first 2015, February 21th - doi: 10.1016/j.physbeh.2015.02.030.
NATANSON, M.A. (ed.) (1970), Phenomenology and Social Reality: Essays in Memory of Alfred Schutz, M. Nijhoff, The Hague.
NIV, D., DEVOR, M. (2004), Chronic Pain as a Disease in its Own Right. In: «Pain Practice», vol. IV, n. 3, pp.179-181.
OSBORN, M., SMITH, J.A. (1998), The Personal Experience of Chronic Benign Lower Back Pain: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. In: «British Journal of Health Psychology», vol. III, n. 1, pp. 65-83.
PANDYA, D.N., BARNES, C.L., PANKSEPP, J. (1987), Architecture and Connections of the Frontal Lobe. In: E. PERECMAN (ed.), The Frontal Lobes Revisited, Erlbaum, Hillsdale (NJ) Erlbaum, pp. 41-72.
PETROVIC, P., KALSO, E., PETERSSON, K.M., INGVAR, M. (2002), Placebo and Opioid Analgesia – Imaging a Shared Neuronal Network. In: «Science», vol. CCXCV, n. 5560, pp. 1737-1740.
PEYRON, R., GARCIA-LARREA, L., GREGOIRE, M.C.L., CONVERS, P., RICHARD, A., LAVENNE, F., BARRAL, F.G., MAUQUIÈR, F., MICHEL, D., LAURENT, B. (2000), Parietal and Cingulate Processes in Central Pain. A Combined Positron Emission tomography (PET) and Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) Study of an Unusual Case. In: «Pain», vol. LXXXIV, n. 1, pp. 77-87.
PLOGHAUS, A., TRACEY, I., GATI, J.S., CLARE, S., MENON, R.S., MATTHEWS, P.M., RAWLINS, J.N. (1999), Dissociating Pain from its Anticipation in the Human Brain. In: «Science», vol. CCLXXXIV, n. 5422, pp. 1979-1981.
POMARES, F.B., FAILLENOT, I., BARRAL, F.G., PEYRON, R. (2013), The “Where” and the “When” of the BOLD Response to Pain in the Insular Cortex. Discussion on Amplitudes and Latencies. In: «NeuroImage», vol. LXIV, n. 1, pp. 466-475.
PRECHTL, H. (1985), Ultrasound Studies of Human Fetal Behavior. In: «Early Human Development», vol. XII, n. 2, pp. 91-98.
PRIBRAM, K.H. (1980), The Biology of Emotions and Other Feelings. In: R. PLUTCHIK, H. KELLER (eds.), Emotion: Theory, Research, and Experience, vol. I, Academic Press, New York, pp. 245-269.
SANDKÜHLER, J., BROMM, B., GEBHART, G.F. (2000), Nervous System Plasticity and Chronic Pain, Elsevier, Amsterdam/New York.
SAWAMOTO, N., HONDA, M., OKADA, T., HANAKAWA, T., KANDA, M., FUKUYAMA, H., KONISHI, J., SHIBASAKI, H. (2000), Expectation of Pain Enhances Responses to Nonpainful Somatosensory Stimulation in the Anterior Cingulate Cortex and Parietal Operculum/Posterior Insula: An Event-related Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study. In: «Journal of Neuroscience», vol. XX, n. 19, pp. 7438-7445.
SCARRY, E. (1985), The Body in Pain: The Making and Unmaking of the World, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
SCHANDRY, R. (1981), Heart Beat Perception and Emotional Experience. In: «Psychophysiology», vol. XVIII, n. 4, pp. 483-488.
SCHANDRY, R., BESTLER, M., MONTOYA, P. (1993), On the Relation between Cardiodynamics and Heartbeat Perception. In: «Psychophysiology», vol. XXX, n. 5, pp. 467-474.
SCHÜTZ, A., LUCKMANN, T. (1973), Structures of the Life World, vol. I., Northwestern University Press, Evanston (IL).
SEARLE, J.R. (1992), The Rediscovery of Mind, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).
SMITH, J.A., OSBORN, M. (2007), Pain as an Assault on the Self: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of the Psychological Impact of Chronic Benign Low Back Pain. In: «Psychology Health», vol. XXII, n. 5, pp. 517-534.
TOOMBS, S.K. (2001), Handbook of Phenomenology and Medicine, Springer, Dordrecht.
TREEDE, R.D., RIEF, W., BARKE, A., AZIZ, Q., BENNETT, M.I., BENOLIEL, R., COHEN, M., EVERS, S., FINNERUP, N.B., FIRST, M.B., GIAMBERARDINO, M.A., KAASA, S., KOSEK, E., LAVAND’HOMME, P., NICHOLAS,M., PERROT, S., SCHOLZ, J., SCHUG, S., SMITH, B.H., SVENSSON, P., VLAEYEN, J.W., WANG, S.J. (2005), A Classification of Chronic Pain for ICD-11. In: «Pain», CLVI, n. 6, pp. 1003-1007.
TURNER, B.H., MISHKIN, M., KNAPP, M. (1980), Organization of the Amygdalopedal Projections from Modality-specific Cortical Association Areas in the Monkey. In: «Journal of Comparative Neurology», vol. CIXI, n. 4, pp. 515-543.
VALLBO, A.B., OLAUSSON, H., WESSBERG, J. (1999), Unmyelinated Afferents Constitute a Second System Coding Tactile Stimuli of the Human Hairy Skin. In: «Journal of Neurophysiology», vol. LXXXI, n. 6, pp. 2753-2763.
WEISS, S., SACK, M., HENNINGSEN, P., POLLATOS, O. (2014), On the Interaction of Self-Regulation, Interoception and Pain Perception. In: «Psychopathology», vol. XLVII, n. 6, pp. 377-382.
WIECH, K., PREISSL, H., BIRBAUMER, N. (2000), Neuroimaging of Chronic Pain: Phantom Limb and Musculoskeletal Pain. In: «Scandinavian Journal of Rheumatology. Supplement», n. 113, pp. 13-18.
WILKE, J.T. (1981), Personal Identity in the Light of Brain Physiology and Cognitive Psychology. In: «Journal of Medicine and Philosophy», vol. VI, n. 3, pp. 323-333.
WILSON, L.B., ANDREW, D., CRAIG, A.D. (2002), Activation of Spinobulbar Lamina I Neurons by Static Muscle Contraction. In: «Journal of Neurophysiology», vol. LXXXVII, n. 3, pp. 1641-1645.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4453/rifp.2016.0018
Copyright (c) 2016 Irene Venturella, Michela Balconi
URLdella licenza: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Rivista internazionale di Filosofia e Psicologia - ISSN: 2039-4667 (print) - E-ISSN: 2239-2629 (online)
Registrazione al Tribunale di Milano n. 634 del 26-11-2010 - Direttore Responsabile: Aurelia Delfino
Web provider Aruba spa - Loc. Palazzetto, 4 - 52011 Bibbiena (AR) - P.IVA 01573850516 - C.F. e R.I./AR 04552920482
Dove non diversamente specificato, i contenuti di Rivista Internazionale di Filosofia e Psicologia sono distribuiti con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione 4.0 Internazionale.